Hogan Development Survey (HDS): The 11 Derailers Explained
What the HDS measures, what each of the 11 derailer scales means, how to read your risk scores, and how employers use the results to shape interviews and leadership hiring decisions.
What the Hogan Development Survey Is
The Hogan Development Survey (HDS) is a personality questionnaire that measures how your behavior tends to change when you are under stress, tired, bored or simply not paying attention to how you come across. Hogan calls these patterns derailers, because they are a common reason capable people stall in their careers. The HDS was developed by Robert and Joyce Hogan and first published in 1997. It is now one of the most widely used "dark side" personality tools in leadership selection and coaching.
The key idea is that most derailers are strengths overused. Confidence can become arrogance, high standards can become micromanagement, and loyalty can become an unwillingness to push back. The HDS does not label you as a bad employee. It shows where, under pressure, your natural style could start to cause problems for you or your team.
| Feature | Hogan Development Survey (HDS) |
|---|---|
| Publisher | Hogan Assessments (Tulsa, Oklahoma) |
| What it measures | 11 derailer scales: behavior under stress and pressure |
| Format | 168 short statements, each marked true or false |
| Time | Untimed; most people finish in 15 to 20 minutes |
| Right or wrong answers? | No; results are compared with a norm group and the role's requirements |
| Usually taken with | The Hogan Personality Inventory (HPI) and the MVPI values inventory |
| Common uses | Leadership and manager hiring, high-potential programs, executive coaching |
If you have been invited to take all three Hogan questionnaires, start with our Hogan assessment overview for the full process, then use this page to understand the HDS in depth.
The 11 HDS Derailer Scales
Each scale describes a pattern that most people show to some degree. A high score means that pattern is more likely to show up, and be noticed by others, when you are under pressure. The middle column shows why the same trait is often valued in normal conditions.
| Scale | Strength side (at its best) | Under pressure (when overused) |
|---|---|---|
| Excitable | Passionate, enthusiastic about new people and projects | Moody, easily frustrated, quick to give up on people or plans |
| Skeptical | Shrewd, alert to hidden motives and politics | Cynical, distrustful, quick to see criticism as an attack |
| Cautious | Careful, thorough in assessing risk | Indecisive, slow to act for fear of failure or criticism |
| Reserved | Calm, independent, tough in difficult situations | Aloof, uncommunicative, unaware of how others feel |
| Leisurely | Polite, cooperative on the surface, protective of own priorities | Quietly resistant, procrastinating, resentful of requests |
| Bold | Confident, decisive, willing to take on big challenges | Arrogant, entitled, unwilling to admit mistakes |
| Mischievous | Charming, persuasive, comfortable with risk | Impulsive, tests limits, bends rules, ignores commitments |
| Colorful | Energetic, engaging, good at drawing attention to a cause | Dramatic, attention-seeking, distractible, poor listener |
| Imaginative | Creative, visionary, thinks in unusual ways | Eccentric, impractical, hard for others to follow |
| Diligent | High standards, organized, reliable on detail | Perfectionist, micromanaging, slow to delegate |
| Dutiful | Loyal, supportive, a good team citizen | Overly eager to please, avoids disagreeing with the boss |
Each of the 11 scales is made up of three subscales, giving 33 in total. The subscales help a coach or assessor explain how a derailer shows up; two people with the same high Diligent score might differ in whether the issue is perfectionism or reluctance to delegate.
A high Diligent score might be a concern for a fast-moving startup general manager and an advantage for a quality-assurance or compliance lead. A high Colorful score can help in sales and hurt in a role that needs quiet, steady analysis. That is why employers compare HDS results with a role profile rather than using a single cut-off.
The Three HDS Clusters
Hogan groups the 11 scales into three clusters, based on psychoanalyst Karen Horney's description of the three ways people tend to cope with stress: moving away from others, moving against them, or moving toward them. Reading the clusters first gives you a quick summary of your overall pressure style.
| Cluster | Scales | Typical pattern under stress | How others may experience it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Moving Away | Excitable, Skeptical, Cautious, Reserved, Leisurely | Pulling back, protecting yourself, keeping people at a distance | Hard to read, defensive, withdrawn or slow to commit |
| Moving Against | Bold, Mischievous, Colorful, Imaginative | Taking charge, pushing your agenda, seeking attention or influence | Overpowering, unpredictable, self-focused |
| Moving Toward | Diligent, Dutiful | Building alliances, seeking approval, following rules closely | Controlling over detail, or too deferential to authority |
Moving Against derailers can be hard to spot early, because they often look like leadership potential in an interview. Confident, persuasive, creative candidates can make a strong first impression. This is one reason organizations add the HDS to leadership hiring: it gives them a structured way to ask whether those same qualities might become a problem once the person is under pressure with real authority.
How HDS Scores Work
HDS results are reported as percentiles, comparing your answers with a large norm group of working adults. A score of 85 on Bold means you answered in a more Bold direction than about 85% of the comparison group. Unlike an aptitude test, a higher number is not better: it means the derailer is more likely to be visible.
| Percentile band | Typical Hogan label | What it usually means |
|---|---|---|
| 0–39 | No risk | The behavior is unlikely to cause problems; very low scores can sometimes point to an under-used strength |
| 40–69 | Low risk | Some tendency, but unlikely to derail you in most situations |
| 70–89 | Moderate risk | Likely to show up under pressure; worth knowing how you manage it |
| 90–100 | High risk | Likely to be noticed by others and to affect relationships or decisions without active management |
Two points surprise most candidates. First, nearly everyone has at least one or two scales in the moderate or high range. A completely flat, low-risk profile is unusual and can suggest that the person answered very defensively. Second, low scores are not automatically ideal. A very low Bold score can mean a lack of confidence in pushing ideas forward, and a very low Diligent score can mean too little attention to detail. Some Hogan reports comment on these low scores as well as the high ones.
In hiring, the employer or its assessment partner usually receives the report, not the candidate. In development programs and coaching, you will often get a full debrief. If you are given a feedback session after a selection process, take it: it is one of the most useful pieces of career feedback you can get.
How Employers Use the HDS in Hiring
The HDS is most common in hiring for managers, senior leaders and roles with significant responsibility for people, money or safety. It is less common for entry-level positions, where employers are more likely to use a short personality questionnaire, a situational judgment test or an aptitude test. Typical uses include:
- Shortlisting against a role profile. The employer or its consultants decide which derailers matter most for the job, then look at whether a candidate's highest scores fall on those scales.
- Planning interview questions. High-risk scales become topics for targeted behavioral questions, so the interviewer can test whether you are aware of the pattern and manage it.
- Final-stage and executive assessment. For senior roles, an occupational psychologist may combine the HDS with the HPI, MVPI, interviews and exercises, often as part of an assessment center or executive assessment day.
- Onboarding and development. After hiring, the same report is often used to shape coaching in the new hire's first year.
Reputable employers treat the HDS as one input among several, not as an automatic pass/fail filter. Hogan's own guidance stresses that derailers describe risks to be managed, and many very successful leaders have high scores on one or two scales.
The HDS scales were informed by research on personality disorders, but the HDS is designed for normal working adults and is not a diagnostic tool. A high score on Skeptical or Excitable says nothing about mental health. It describes a workplace pattern that shows up under stress.
Interview Questions Linked to Each Derailer
When HDS results are used to plan an interview, the questions are usually standard behavioral interview questions chosen to probe a specific risk. Knowing the likely link helps you prepare honest examples that show self-awareness. The table below shows common pairings.
| High scale | Question you might be asked | What a strong answer shows |
|---|---|---|
| Excitable | "Tell me about a time a project or colleague frustrated you." | You noticed your reaction, stayed constructive and did not give up on the person |
| Skeptical | "Describe a time you received critical feedback." | You took the feedback at face value and acted on it |
| Cautious | "Tell me about a decision you made without all the information." | You managed the risk but still moved forward |
| Reserved | "How do you keep your team informed when things are going wrong?" | You communicate early and check in on how people are doing |
| Leisurely | "Tell me about a time you disagreed with a priority you were given." | You raised the concern openly instead of quietly resisting |
| Bold | "Tell me about a mistake you made and what you learned." | Genuine ownership of a real mistake, without excuses |
| Mischievous | "Describe a time you had to follow a rule you disagreed with." | You respected the commitment and pushed for change through the right channels |
| Colorful | "Tell me about a time you let someone else take the lead." | You listened, gave credit and stayed focused on the goal |
| Imaginative | "How did you turn one of your ideas into something practical?" | You tested the idea and delivered it step by step |
| Diligent | "Tell me about a time you delegated something important." | You let go of control and coached rather than redid the work |
| Dutiful | "Describe a time you challenged your manager." | You disagreed respectfully and stood by your view when it mattered |
Several of these are classic questions in their own right. For detailed answer frameworks, see our guides to stress interview questions and "what are your weaknesses?", which is often where a derailer conversation begins.
HDS vs HPI vs MVPI (and Other Personality Tests)
The HDS is one of three core Hogan instruments. Each answers a different question about you, which is why employers often use all three together.
| HPI | HDS | MVPI | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Question it answers | How do you usually come across? | What could get in your way under pressure? | What motivates you and what culture suits you? |
| Hogan's label | Bright side | Dark side | Inside |
| Number of scales | 7 primary scales | 11 derailer scales | 10 values scales |
| Items and format | 206, true/false | 168, true/false | 200, agree/uncertain/disagree |
| Higher score means | More of the trait (good or bad depends on the role) | More risk | Stronger value or motive |
| Main use | Predicting job performance | Predicting derailment and coaching needs | Predicting engagement and culture fit |
Other publishers measure personality in different ways. The SHL OPQ32 uses forced-choice blocks across 32 dimensions. The Predictive Index and DISC are shorter behavioral-style tools, more often used for team fit and development. None of these has a direct equivalent to the HDS derailer focus. For a broader comparison, see our workplace personality test guide.
How to Prepare for the HDS
You cannot study for the HDS the way you study for a numerical test, and trying to "beat" it usually backfires. What you can do is understand the format, take it in the right conditions, and prepare for the conversation that follows.
- Read the 11 scales honestly. Pick the two or three you think are most like you under pressure, and ask a trusted colleague whether they agree.
- Prepare one example per likely derailer. For each, have a real story showing that you noticed the pattern and handled it. Use the STAR structure and end with what you changed.
- Take it when you are rested. The HDS is untimed, but tired or rushed answers tend to be less consistent.
- Answer from your typical behavior at work. Do not answer as your ideal self or as the person you think the employer wants.
- Do not overthink single items. Each scale is built from many statements, so one answer rarely changes a result. Go with your first honest reaction.
- Prepare for the debrief. If an interviewer raises a derailer, agree where it is fair, give your example, and describe the habits you use to manage it.
Interviewers who use HDS data are rarely looking for a candidate with no derailers. They are looking for someone who knows their pressure patterns and has practical ways to manage them. "Under deadline pressure I tend to take work back from my team, so I now agree check-in points up front instead" is exactly the kind of answer they hope to hear.
If the employer also uses ability tests, that is where practice raises your score directly. Our timed numerical, verbal and inductive reasoning practice tests are the best use of preparation time for that part of the process, and our leadership interview questions guide covers the interview stage that usually follows a Hogan assessment.
Frequently Asked Questions
Facing Aptitude Tests Alongside Hogan?
Many leadership and graduate processes pair personality questionnaires with timed reasoning tests. Practice numerical, verbal and logical reasoning for free.
Keep reading
- Guide · Test TypesHogan Assessment Test 2026: HPI, HDS & MVPI Explained
- Article · Test TypesHogan Personality Inventory (HPI): The 7 Scales, Subscales and Scores Explained
- Article · Test TypesHogan MVPI: The 10 Motives, Values and Preferences Scales Explained
- Guide · Test TypesInductive Reasoning Tests Explained
- Guide · Test TypesAptitude Tests Explained
- Guide · Test TypesMechanical Reasoning Tests Explained